Mac, it is all about your preference. If you like your dealer, and they are strong BRP, then go Evinrude. If you like Mercury, then go Merc. The choices are yours and you will only be happy long term if it is what you wanted. Lets look at it like this, if it broke which one would you feel better about owning. No matter which one is to break, which one would you feel best about? That is the one we would buy.