I would have to say that personal preference plays a big roll in this one …. Ive driven both , and my preference is hand controls , as Ive got my thumb on a trim switch all the time , and I feel Ive got better throttle control as well . — I didnt like the foot throttle operation in rough water . — It was real easy to chop the throttle when bouncing through some situations , and the last thing I want to do is hook another one . — Not fun !!