Sounds like u have alot of slippage. May b running plate a little to high or a little too much trim. Prop may have lost some bite too if it has alot of hours on it. If you went to a 26 Fury you should lose about 200 rpm. I have a Puma FTD and with the 25 Fury with 2 guys, full fuel, 2 poles, 4 batteries, livewells full etc., in the summer heat, I turn about 5900 at 76ish