O own a P4 so I might be a bit biased. That said, I would have no problem buying a P2, but I cant really convince my self the reason I would want a P2 over a P4 other than speed, and really what is it, 2-3 MPH? Never ridden in a P2, but most of the postings I see here seem to say the P4 rides better, and some say it is the best riding Cat. Maybe it is because I am rapidly approaching 40, but Id give up 3 MPH for a better ride. And I can get 70 with 2 guys in my P4, I dont need more than that. I would definitely miss the net storage of the P4, the beam is an inch smaller (though I cant tell i the deck is), the boat is 4 inches shorter, and teh rear storage compartments look smaller. I guess the cooler in the P2 looks bigger (which would be nice). What am I missing?