I have fished out of both many times . The P-4 rides better, fishes better,its like a smaller puma.The p2 is a great boat and its the one I would buy because of the one thing it does better .Its a little faster 3-5 mph .good luck with your future BASS CAT boat.I have owned 4 Bass Cat boats since 07 I think they are the best all around bass boats out there.